If you're looking at a new MMO with comparable graphics and a subscription, those 2 are the only games that come to mind.

btw, I know wildstar started catering to the hardcore raiding playerbase (it's a small fanbase but consider it if its your thing), while ESO recently removed their 6-month subscription option (a distressing sign considering they have made no comment on why yet). For all their great features, ffxiv is probably the most successful of the recent releases. Keep that in mind and know that many players consider the game a tutorial until you hit lv.50 when the class/job is actually complete and you can unlock all the dungeons.

Good luck and maybe i'll see you online.