I was finally able to log on today. I was following the thread about Verizon Fios, pinging 199.91.189.74 NA data centers and noticed I could not ping or tracert.

I am on Windows 8.1, my firewall was controlled by Nod32 aka ESET. Now I disabled that and still could not log on or ping or tracert. I checked my router for ICMP and all that jazz. So I decided to uninstall ESET, reboot, turn windows firewall off and well boom I am back on.

Even though i disabled ESET something was still preventing me. I feel pretty dumb for just not doing this before hand, but I hope this helps anyone in the future.