Quote Originally Posted by SirTaint View Post

Lavieh: the ideal rotation is WAR tanking when unchained is available and PLD tanking when its down. T12 is an excellent fight for tanks to DPS. I sword oath close to 90 seconds in Phase 1-2 and that's not even optimized. I do stay in Shield oath while MTing which allows our SCH to go in full DPS mode. SCH DPS has allowed us to push 1 blackfire, 4 Bennu NP and we only see 4 fountains. (one dodge phase)
Gear and player comfortability.

Our PLD stays Sword Oath and our SCH full time DPS. We push 3 Bennu's though and we have gotten lucky with Tank gear. While it is a known fact that in tank stances WAR does more damage, PLD is an overall better choice for MT because of mitigation and healer DPS. Only point I am trying to refute is that WAR as the tank vs PLD as the tank has little to no impactful difference and in most cases PLD will be the better choice for MTing for both DPS and safety reasons.