No More Classes?

[Kuwagami]

While I agree with you, the Job Crystal is what changes the specific roles. For examble take the Arcanist Jobs, Arcanist by itself is a dps class, attach a SCH job crystal and now you're a healer. So if you are a THM for example and you equip the DK crystal, you will become a tank. The crystal itself can have a base HP that it starts off with etc. It's not entirely a stretch.

Without the crystal they are mere classes rather than a job. To me the crystal is what separates the two.

It's all hypothetical and the expansion will define it all.

though THM (in your example) has absolutely no tank options, where ACN has a bunch of supportive healing options (physics, E4E, virus, raise).

[Wintersandman]

though THM (in your example) has absolutely no tank options, where ACN has a bunch of supportive healing options (physics, E4E, virus, raise).

The only supportive healing options are Raise and Physicks. Other classes can do debuffs like your referring to.

They've also said they aren't considered Jobs because they don't have a base class, and they're called "extra jobs". So if anything, they'll just be like a class with higher stats to make up for not having the stats from a Job Crystal.

Again without the crystal, you can call them a Job but in all actuality there is nothing to distinguish them from classes.

The requirements are that you have to have a class to 30 to even unlock. If they don't have a crystal and it is just a weapon why even bother calling them a 'Job' and not just call them a class.

Let's be honest 'Extra Job' is just silly. It is just a way to define why they are doing something differently. If they called them a class, then everyone would assume that they could upgrade them later on. If they called them a 'Job' everyone would assume there is a base class. But by calling them an "Extra Job" is really just a way to appease the masses and keep it simple on their end without having to go into any further explanation.

This guy explains exactly that.

I don't think classes are being thrown out all together.. why 3.0 jobs don't have classes, imo, is based out of necessity

1. level increase to 60
2. 3 new Jobs being introduced simultaneously

In the PAX interview YoshiP mentioned how difficult doing 3 new jobs at once was for the battle team. I think they have gone this 'no class' route for these 3.0 jobs specifically to ease the balancing issues that arise from creating new classes.

If these 3 had base classes, then the battle team would have had to QA Test all 3 classes as well as the 3 jobs. This task becomes exponentially more difficult when you consider that classes have access to ALL cross-class abilities.. I think they did it this way just to make their job easier, and to get the new jobs balanced and ready for 3.0 launch on time.

[Kuwagami]

The only supportive healing options are Raise and Physicks. Other classes can do debuffs like your referring to.

I know no other class which can drastically reduce incoming damage like that. Bard had "10% less damage" RoD in 2.0 but got nerfed to current version so it's not in the question.

Virus and E4E are supportive skills designed for a healer. (as there is no debuffing job in FFxiv)

[Wintersandman]

Virus and E4E are supportive skills designed for a healer. (as there is no debuffing job in FFxiv)

Monk - Dragon Kick, Warrior - Storm's Path, Paladin - Rage of Halone, and Black Mage - Apocatastasis all support buffing or debuffing which affect healing. Also if you look at SMN it fits more with their toolkit as their dots, etc debuff as well as inflict damage. I wouldn't say those skills are healer specific.

[Cariborne]

Monk - Dragon Kick, Warrior - Storm's Path, Paladin - Rage of Halone, and Black Mage - Apocatastasis all support buffing or debuffing which affect healing. Also if you look at SMN it fits more with their toolkit as their dots, etc debuff as well as inflict damage. I wouldn't say those skills are healer specific.

Dragon Kick increases the damage a Monk does. Not really a support skill. Storm's Path and Rage of Halone lower the damage the enemy does with Melee Attacks. Not really a support skill, more a defensive ability for the tank. Apoc is a Support skill, I'll give you that one. Eye for an Eye and Virus are also Support skills, and really if you can have Eye for an Eye you should have it. Virus should be with the Scholar and the summoner though, unless you're missing one or doing dungeons without one.

As for the Extra Job, they're called that because they aren't the usual Job, and they dont use a Class. Square said they messed up on Classes, so they'd probably move away from them.

[Wintersandman]

Snip.

Dragon Kick does more than you think it does. Also if you look at what I stated (buffing or debuffing which affect healing). Also with the Cooldown on virus WHM and BLM should have it as well.

As for the Extra Job, they're called that because they aren't the usual Job, and they dont use a Class. Square said they messed up on Classes, so they'd probably move away from them.

Again you entirely missed what I said. "calling them an "Extra Job" is really just a way to appease the masses and keep it simple on their end without having to go into any further explanation."