I'm aware I ramble a bit in this, but bear with me if you decide to read it all. TL;DR is the gist lol.
I'm not exactly against being able to customize music for each zone, but I'd rather not see music packs as DLC at all. Such DLC works fine for multi-series games like Dissidia FF and Theathrhythm FF, but not for an MMO with it's own soundtrack.
I am aware of the fact that we have a few reworks of past FF music that isn't the Prelude, Main Theme of FF, or the Chocobo theme (such as themes used in Labyrinth of the Ancients/Syrcus Tower, and Battle on the Big Bridge) and one direct rip from another game (FF6 boss battle). This isn't counting the music used for special events (LR:FFXIII, FFXI, and Dragon Quest).
Each of the reworked/reused songs used served a specific purpose. For example; the reworked CT musics are there because it's based on the final areas of Final Fantasy III, the music is memorable and nostalgic for some. The Crystal Tower theme itself is fairly well known in the series, despite it not being used in multiple games (to my knowledge), it's kind of one of those "we had to" moments I think. Another example is Battle on the Big Bridge. It is one of the most well known themes from Final Fantasy, and it's essentially Gilgamesh's theme. To not use the theme would be a disappointment to the fans for that very reason, as Gilgamesh is a recurring character in the Final Fantasy series and the theme has been reworked on multiple occasions.
This is in contrast to the themes used from FFXI, FFXIII, and DQ, as they were event specific. The tracks were used nowhere else in the game and only resurfaced when the events were relaunched. Personally, I'd rather not have them be used again unless an event using those games again is made.
Then there's the original FF6 boss battle theme in the game. The purpose was mainly to make people nostalgic for a silly fight in the Hildibrand storyline. I would have preferred a rework like the other themes got, but I'd be lying if I wasn't extremely happy when the theme started playing.
If we were able to say, select certain boss music for specific fights, it kind of renders the point of the music chosen for the boss moot. I'm well aware of how tiresome music can become. And while I do like the theme for the final boss of a dungeon, I have grown tired of it. But still, I'd rather new compositions be written for future dungeons and fights rather than just be given the option to replace X theme with Y theme.
It's kind of the same thing with replacing other songs in the game. What reason is there for Tifa's theme to be used as a fishing theme (using your example)? What reason is there for it to be in the game? I think the only way the theme would make an appearance is if Tifa shows up in an FF7 related event. Perhaps Fisherman's Horizon could make an appearance (seeing as how they used FF2's battle theme in a couple story battles), but regardless, in most cases the reused music has had reason to be in the game.
What would be the purpose for older FF music showing up (even as DLC)? Simply just to replace the current themes made specifically for FFXIV? What would be the point of composing new music for FFXIV when people can just place another theme over it with an in game option when they can recycle so much music?
TL;DR
I'm not against a BGM selector for certain types of content, but I'm not for it either. I personally probably wouldn't use the BGM selector if we got one.
Regarding Cash Shop: I'd rather new compositions be written for the game over having DLC packs containing music from past games (even if remixed). DLC music seems like a VERY bad idea for the game. Currently, the majority of recycled music served specific purposes (Battle on the Big Bridge = Gilgamesh fight, FFXIII music specifically for FFXIII related content) and is included with the content given to us because of our monthly service payments.
And if we get more recycled music, it should have good reason to be there. The only FF themes I can currently see returning with a justified reason are the Gold Saucer theme (+ possible minigames) and more Final Fantasy III CT music (specifically the final boss theme and the Dark World theme, possibly Eureka's theme as well) since they're coming relatively soon.


Reply With Quote







