The Ninja Superthread

[Arkenne]

I would rather it have a way to buff the next GCD, since well, we are already pretty tight GCD wise...
Adding just one GCD skill totally messes up my rotation, at least :/

For example:
If the way to increase Huton duration is really a new GCD that extends from Gust Slash, then every time I was supposed to use Aeolian Edge would be replaced by this new skill, depending on if its also potency/TP-wise-worth. But there is a risk of never again using Aeolian Edge this way.

If the new GCD actually extends from Shadow Fang instead, it looks much more friendly and healthy for the NIN GCD rotation, imo.

Im still crossing fingers for positionals to be the ones that boosts Huton's duration, since that would be more interesting. For me, at least.

[Dante_V]

I would rather it have a way to buff the next GCD, since well, we are already pretty tight GCD wise...
Adding just one GCD skill totally messes up my rotation, at least :/

For example:
If the way to increase Huton duration is really a new GCD that extends from Gust Slash, then every time I was supposed to use Aeolian Edge would be replaced by this new skill, depending on if its also potency/TP-wise-worth. But there is a risk of never again using Aeolian Edge this way.

I don't really see how and even coming after gust slash it would still be a dps increase assuming the move has a potency of attack which considering it is a weapon skill it likely does.

Huton has a length of 70 seconds currently. Under huton the GCD is about 2.1 seconds depending on you SS. Maybe a little more or less. Lets just use 2 as a number for simplification purposes.

SE>GS>DE>SE>SF>MU>SE>GS>AE is one "full gcd rotation" applying all debuffs/dots.

At 2 seconds the total accounts for 18 seconds. The next rotation will be 2 seconds shorter due to mutilate not needing a refresh until the following cycle.

So if the cycles are 18 + 16 + 18 + 16 = 68 out of 70 seconds of huton. You will be doing the new move to refresh huton in battle negating 1 aeolian edge out of every 4 roughly speaking.

So there is no risk of losing every aeolian unless you don't know how to play the class.

Beyond that lets analyze the current state of huton:

As it sits now huton is a dps loss albeit a necessary one. Every time you have to cast huton with a 3 mudra combo instead or raiton or suiton you are losing a good bit of dps. Over the course of a fight this adds up. Especially for those with mudra lag and high pings it will clip into their next gcd resulting in sometime up to a 1 second clip. Over time this translated to lost gcds.

Also you can't forget those times when you have 15 seconds left on huton and have a mudra ready leaving you to either hold the mudra or clip the huton. Both are an effective dps loss since you are not casting a damage mudra.
The new method will effectively eliminate this issue. If you have 15 second left on huton, or even 10, you will now be able to cast raiton without worrying about the loss of huton because it can be applied in about 6 seconds with no mudra loss.

My point being is that the loss from one aeolian edge out of four will be much smaller than you think and it certainly won't negate every aeolian edge by any means. The additional ability to cast huton out of mudra will be a substantial dps increase because there will be no need to use a mudra to do it in battle meaning every mudra can than be allocated to an attack.

[Arkenne]

Replacing Aeolian Edge? BLASPHEMOUS!!

Well, first and foremost I said it was a "risk" depending on how this mysterious skill will work... we dont even know its name :/
Another thing is that I understand how much benefit it would come out of extending Huton. Specially since I suffer of this mudra lag crap like hell.

What I am trying to express is my worry about this new skill coming out of the Spinning -> Gust Slash combo in comparison to Spinning -> Shadow Fang combo. Or well, even after Mutilate sounds good to me.

All I am based on are speculations. So its not really worth much for a theorycrafty heavy reaction :/
Please spare me the "you don't know the class" comments...

On this note, the article says this skill extends from Gust Slash, but in the video they show a new one after Shadow Fang... and in that same video they use a skill that in the Benchmark is used after Mutilate but Mutilate isnt used in the video... adding to the confusion...

TL;DR if there will be a new GCD, I would rather it be after Shadow Fang or Mutilate. Not Gust Slash.

[Dante_V]

The report say its after gust slash so that what I'm basing it off of. That doesn't mean one of the other moves isn't comboing off of shadow fang tho because that's very much possible.