New claim system, the death of open world content?

[Phenidate]

Only took the time to read the OP long post.

Coming from FFXI, I must say I really got accustomed to the claiming system there. I have tried on other F2P MMO's a sorta free for all system where everyone can attack anything regardless if its claimed or not, I must say, I did not enjoy that.

Can't say random F2P games would be a good place to find 'good mehanics'. In the case of world events and open fights, I'd say the system in Warhammer did a good job of rewarding participation. If you are there from the start and participate in a given events objectives, you received the full EXP reward and equal chance at good loot. If you jumped in at the end or just stood around, you'd be lucky to get anything.

Really in the end that's how any event where anyone can jump in should be handled. No one should be rewarded for showing up and putting on a pretty face unless its a beauty contest.