Master Book II Lottery

[Mishini_Dracoto]

If you're using WN, you're praying for Excellent at the right time.

Go for 2 MMIIs, and if you don't get at least 6-7 ToT procs reclaim and try again.

Praying for an Excellent, or a Good condition, and making the best with what I have if it doesn't come.

Are you saying you just go through MM2 a second time, and when you get 11 stacks you just keep going / blow our BB on an excellent condition should it show itself?

[StouterTaru]

Are you saying you just go through MM2 a second time, and when you get 11 stacks you just keep going / blow our BB on an excellent condition should it show itself?

Pretty much, with 2 MMIIs you are looking at 12-14 shots at Hasty Touch. If you don't have enough CP to do your final run or didn't hit enough Hasties, then Reclaim out.

Lots of varying advice. Lets just take a poll of how much FC3s it took you guys for your masterbooks

For me,

ARM: 10 FC3s
LTW: 10 FC3s
GSM: 12 FC3s
CUL: 12 FC3s
ALC: 18 FC3s (Bad luck here)

Rotation is this http://i.imgur.com/H1FkdFL.png

Technically speaking Rapid Synthesis rotations have a slight edge on HQ chance, but they take twice as long to do before you know if you have to reclaim or not.

I didn't have supras when I made mine, so the only FCIIIs I wasted were on failed reclaims. I wound up with 1-5 NQ in each synth when I hit 3 HQ.

I wasn't keeping track but I would estimate about 20-25 failed reclaims between all 8 books, but only 4 or 5 total on my last four books.

I think Rapid is overrated for normal synths, but since these are swing for the fences style it can helpful.

[Kimura410]

If you're using WN, you're praying for Excellent at the right time.

Go for 2 MMIIs, and if you don't get at least 6-7 ToT procs reclaim and try again.

not necessarily. i use wn when i do the turn ins and i never count on excellent. i shoot for 10 stacks and a good, which is not totally uncommon if you use observe or throw an innovation in to try to get a good to pop. in the 7 classes ive mastered, only 2 gave me some trouble, but i was still perfecting my rotation and when to do certiain abilities. 5 classes i mastered, i used 8 fieldcraft 3s on average per class.

im the type to risk it to, like letting sh fall off when im about to bb if it means that i can possibly get a good to proc. way i look at it, the non SH BB is the same rng as reclaim. on top of that, i only need 2 TOT. this means all the other hastys i can hit on good condition, meaning more quality.


but yea, you basically need at least a good to pop, because even with 11 stacks, normal is not good enough. highest i got was around 30% with a normal 11 stack iq, and that was with full melds new offhand and supra.

[Lebenoshl]

Lots of varying advice. Lets just take a poll of how much FC3s it took you guys for your masterbooks

For me,

ARM: 10 FC3s
LTW: 10 FC3s
GSM: 12 FC3s
CUL: 12 FC3s
ALC: 18 FC3s (Bad luck here)

Rotation is this http://i.imgur.com/H1FkdFL.png

Technically speaking Rapid Synthesis rotations have a slight edge on HQ chance, but they take twice as long to do before you know if you have to reclaim or not.

[Rath]

Technically speaking Rapid Synthesis rotations have a slight edge on HQ chance, but they take twice as long to do before you know if you have to reclaim or not.

I do something like your guide picture, but, I do things in a different order.

Edit around 100 char limit:

I do the following and take ALL ToT that come up regardless of timing and refresh CZ when down (after using ToT of course):
CZ
IQ
SH2
PbPx2
RSx2 (refresh SH2 if needed)
HT if SH2 is up, otherwise 1 cs2 (leaves me with 3 progress)
sh2 ht until 10 dura
mm2

Now here I will sh2 ht until 20 dura (refresh cz if 220 or more cp and 40 or more dura)
at 20 durability mm2 repeat as necessary
HT until 20 durability if you don't have enough cp for sh2 (use sh2 if you get a tot right away) or sh2 ht until 30 durability
reclaim if under 10 stacks or else finish (how you finish depends on goods/cp/etc. I will try to sh2>ht>gs>innovation>BB then cs2, bb if good or excellent pops though.

There have been times when I have had copious ammounts of CP and will just mm2 again to build more quality already having 11 stacks. Generally I use reclaim 1-2 times for each successful attempt. For 3 star artisan tools you can drop 1 pbp and a cs2.

[Mishini_Dracoto]

Lots of varying advice. Lets just take a poll of how much FC3s it took you guys for your masterbooks

For me,

ARM: 10 FC3s
LTW: 10 FC3s
GSM: 12 FC3s
CUL: 12 FC3s
ALC: 18 FC3s (Bad luck here)

Rotation is this http://i.imgur.com/H1FkdFL.png

Technically speaking Rapid Synthesis rotations have a slight edge on HQ chance, but they take twice as long to do before you know if you have to reclaim or not.

I actually still don't have any Supras, so this is very ambiguous. I bought the materials to craft m Supra, as well as get my Mastercraft II book. That requires 8 items / 16 FC3's. Since I didn't waste any, I can technically say 6?

ARM: 6
BSM: 6
GSM: 6

& I'll be doing this on LTW in the near future.

[Espritduo]

No matter what rotation you used (I've tried em all), the end result is you are at the mercy of RNG. I have had wildly varying results with my FCIII usage per book, and have at the moment what I feel is a pretty solid (and flexible depending on how it goes) rotation. And yet my most recent book was by far my worst. So it goes.

For what it's worth, here is my success rate with these accursed tomes:

1. CRP - 6 wasted FCIII's
2. BSM - 0 wasted FCIII's
3. WVR - 2 wasted FCIII's
4. GSM - 4 wasted FCIII's
5. LTW - 8 wasted FCIII's
6. ARM - 22 wasted FCIII's

I have only improved my rotation since my Carpenter book, and yet my ARM run was just god awful, with ridiculously bad luck across the board (low Hasty/Rapid success, low ToT proc rate, numerous failed reclaims, high % chances that still nq'd, etc). Also, simple human error where I pushed the wrong button or took a dumb risk I shouldn't have has probably accounted for at least a fourth of my wasted FCIII's. Shit happens when you've been at a book for over half an hour and are seething with unmitigated fury at RNJezebel.

I will be doing my ALC book today, and I expect many tears.

EDIT: Many tears were had indeed, but I managed to balance the usual ridiculously impossible bad luck with a couple strokes of good luck and wasted 8 FCIII's for my ALC book. One more book left and the worst thing ever added to this game will be behind me.

[Hayward]

If we're expected to HQ 4-star items, Hasty Touch + Steady Hand II need to add up to 100% success rate. 80% is obviously not enough with this RNG system.

[scarebearz]

If we're expected to HQ 4-star items, Hasty Touch + Steady Hand II need to add up to 100% success rate. 80% is obviously not enough with this RNG system.

I.e. you want a 100% macro for the highest tier of crafting?

This is nonsense tbh, the highest tier of crafting should require both skill and some luck.

Any good 4* crafter will have a very very high HQ rate and the difficulty if anything if too easy already for 4*, especially those where you can start on 2.7k quality from all HQ mats.