When is it OK to say, "It's Not OK"

[Tiggy]

Understanding why someone does something and the reasoning behind it , and suggesting you have no business telling people what to do is not the same as what Bob said. Any reasonable person, and even those in that thread, can understand that. Striving for understanding of something does not mean you inherit the qualities of it. Believing that you don't have a right to tell anyone how to play doesn't make me instantly supportive of the actions either. I simply think you should mind your own business and leave people alone. Those clear sellers don't prevent anyone from working on the turns. They don't stop anyone from grabbing friends, queuing up, and working on it until they get a win. If you want to down T5 so bad then people should spent less time fuming about clear sellers and more time in T5 working on it. There are not enough people in the game for clear sellers to prohibit you from completing this content. The only thing preventing people (in no specific importance or order) is some combination of lack of time, lack of dedication dedication, and finding 7 competent people to assist you.

I am a raider. You generalize actions to all raiders, therefore you mean me, all the other nice raiders I know, and more. It doesn't matter if your specific statement doesn't represent me for me to find it offensive because it targets raiders which is a group I most definitely identify with. That's no different than making a blanket racist statement and then looking over at your friend who is a member of that race and saying "sorry, I didn't mean you though bro." It's still greatly offensive. The real solution would be for you to fix your rhetoric and to stop referring to all raiders collectively. Say "Some of the more malicious raiders" instead of the collective "raiders" or something to that effect. It's not that hard to prevent yourself from being offensive to an overly large group of people that don't all represent the specific demographic you're talking about. The way you're doing it is no better than racism. Showing prejudice and disdain for an entire group of people based on the actions and behaviors from a subset of them.

Implying that 99% of the player base who haven't touched FCoB is incompetent and all our friends are equally so. Why should the rest of us have to take insults like this in silence?

Despite how ridiculously out of context that quote is, that player who said it doesn't represent all raiders. A point I've been trying to get across to you from the beginning. Pointing out any one bad player doesn't make the whole group bad just as no good player makes the whole group good. Your quote only makes your argument look more petty and short sighted.

Even despite that specific example the advice to "Make more friends" and "become a member of more communities" is sound. It's good advice for any new player to any MMO in existence, and will lead to wins with enough determination.

*drops mic and walks out*

[NyarukoW]

.... That's no different than making a blanket racist statement and then looking over at your friend who is a member of that race and saying "sorry, I didn't mean you though bro." It's still greatly offensive. ...

I don't make racist remarks or off-color jokes ever. I am the one odd minority in group setting more often than not given the current existing U.S. demographics. And I know that one does NOT make the group.

Pointing out any one bad player doesn't make the whole group bad just as no good player makes the whole group good.

But that doesn't mean you let those off-color jokes slip and let the norm continue as it is. That is why you call out the one that behaving badly. But somehow that gets turned into generalization? Fact is this kind of hatred and contempt for new/newer players the so called "need to get good" is all too common on these forums. If it feels like generalization, is because by the de facto environment that exist too much of this is going on already, and this need correcting.

[craig_meredith2003]

[Tiggy]

And just because you can't find evidence of their connection to RMT, does NOT mean it does not exist. And if you can NOT imagine it, that just means like the tunnel vision and the limited scope you choose to see.

Absence of evidence is not evidence to the contrary. That's the "Arguement from Ignorance" fallacy. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argumen...ce_of_evidence

[Schizm]

Well after spending some time just scanning the forums and thinking about playing FFXIV, I decided to stop playing. WIth other threads about the trinity system, all I see for my character is logging in and waiting for DF to pop to get seals. When the events pop, I am still finding the same arguement coming up on gear and experienced players.

I am not saying my time was wasted, I really did enjoy the times and exploring a new world, I might just wait til the expansion comes out to decide to come back or not.

[Excalibur:Schizm Gallantry] Peace Out! <(O.o)>