NIN Opener / Rotation

[Butcherboy]

Yes it'll get stronger to 100 potency but that's nothing really to brag about

[Alistaire]

Yes it'll get stronger to 100 potency but that's nothing really to brag about

Not sure what you think other jobs do for aoe but here's some #'s:
MNK: 50, 0, 130, repeating, 170 off gcd every minute. NIN wins. (except perfect balance rockbreaker spam every 4 minutes @ 130 repeating)
BRD: 110 repeating, 35 dot up half the time, bonus if with a caster. Without caster involvement I'm sure it's close if not slightly less than nin.
DRG: 100 repeating unless neatly lined up, then 160 repeating but elevated tp cost. 250 off gcd every 2 minutes
SMN: kinda hard to calculate but goes down when there's 5+ mobs.
BLM: even the king of aoe is still mostly doing 100 potency hits a high amount of the time, just with things that boost it.

NIN aoe is just fine. Better than MNK and possibly preferable to all but BLM when paired with another melee and/or war tank.

[Qooo]

BLM aoe should be Fire II 180 potency and Flare 468 potency under Astral 3.