Goad

[LionKing]

t

this guy knows whats up

And I know I can do all that without the need of Goad.
First, no Defiance=> No stacks, Infuriate, Steel Cyclone
Second, his Mp bar is full => No flash has been used. It is right there, cost 28 MP to use.
Third, look at aggro meter, none of the other aggro meter has even a slight fill on it. Meaning he was way overhead of them in aggro wise =>There is no need to keep spamming OP.

Look at this pictures, all I see is the Tank is the DPS more than a tank and he's is trying to DpS more than actually caring for aggro and managing his TP. I don't know the purpose for you to post this picture but all it shows is a Tank doing the DPs job. Not that I am criticise him or anything, it is always a good skill to be able to DPS while still maintaining aggro. However in this case, the Ninja already know what the Tank want, he want to DPS, not to do the Tanking, and Ninja appreciate it. That is why he throw out Goad to help him. => Good

In our case, we have a Tank acting like a Tank and still demand for Goad while expecting Ninja throw out for him without him asking, then go AWOL => Bad/rude.

There are two different cases we have here.

Edit; My bad for not checking the level of the party, even though, a Goad or not, the Tank can still holding aggro just fine like the age before Goad even existed. Nothing changed besides Goad is added. Before, a Tank has no trouble holding aggro. After, they need Goad to do the SAME job. Why?