Oh, thanks for the replies, everyone! It still seems like most people agree that WAR is more fun with a bit more to pay attention to while PLD is your more straight forward 'sword and shield' tank. Which is really helpful! I'm going to level PLD for bit until I'm more proficient in tanking and then give WAR a try. Still thinking WAR is going to be my favorite of the two in the end. Lots of helpful points here too!