WAR or PLD?

[reality_check]

Warrior benefits:
25% more health
20% more healing taken
10% less damage done by enemies
Increased slashing damage taken by enemies
Better DPS
Stun off GC with cooldown

Paladin benefits:
20% less damage taken
Random shield block mitigation
Better cooldowns
5% less strength on enemies
Stun without cooldown on GCD

Every single encounter in the game is doable with any tank combination pretty much. If there's only one tank, I prefer warrior over paladin because of 10% less damage done by the enemy.

Certain moments in the game lend themselves MUCH better to Hallowed Ground over Holmgang.

Warrior has more engaging play, in my opinion.