BCNMs

[Deo]

I was trying to be nice, but since you asked for it:

If I'm not mistaken, they were called Burning Circle Notorious Monsters. So what you meant to say was: "I don't know wtf I'm talking about, but I wanna post something because I think it's cool"

I don't see how this proves he knows nothing about the BCNM system, it was hardly as if anyone referred to them by anything other than "BCNM" anyway.

Wow yah! That's just like BCNMs! You even thought up a new name for them! Congratulations! You go on and keep thinking you know what a BCNM is!

Unnecessarily harsh, the OP is just putting forward a suggestion.

Guild marks, huh? Sounds good. You, me, and a group of marauders can all get together with our stockpile of marauder's guild marks and give em hell! We can do it without a healer! Yah! What an absolutely awful -- er, I mean -- great idea!

Or maybe we can just solo them - which circles right back to: You don't know wtf a BCNM is still.

At no point did the OP say that if you did one in a marauders guild you had to be in a group of only Marauders, making up points for the sake of argument is pointless.

Yah! We should get weapons, accessories, and everything else from it too! Screw other content!

Again, you are making up points for the sake of your own argument. At no point does the OP say that this should be in place of other content. What is your problem anyway, surely this IS content and a way of gaining items? If i recall correctly BCNM's DID reward weapons, accessories and a plethora of other items?

What guild is Maat in?

I think he was referring to the location of the fight, as it is in a BCNM location. At no point did the OP say Maat was in a guild or even imply he is...

You were thinking when you wrote this?

You didn't even read what the OP wrote properly so perhaps you should think before you write your posts?

My thoughts:

I like the idea, especially the point of using guild marks to perform them. I'm sure we all have a large stockpile of them after we have bought all the abilities so why not use them to do something fun, and potentially get a reward?