I think a lot of posters are taking this thread the wrong way. I don't think Audacity asked for any specific content from FFXI to be duplicated in FFXIV, but rather that some of the broad strokes that made that content great in FFXI could also be applied to FFXIV.

Like having more than one type of end game raid. It doesn't have to be Sky and Dynamis exactly, but rather that multiple end game raids can be running side by side each week, like Sky and Dynamis did.

Or having alliance based end game content. Again, he isn't asking for Dynamis itself, but end game content that includes as many participants as Dynamis did.

I have to agree with Audacity for the most part, particularly point number 4. I like end game rewards to have a little more staying power than the timeframe FFXIV uses, but I think something else would have to be added to make stats interesting enough for horizontal gear progression to work.