SE please dont make mudra's macroable

[jomoru]

i dont use any macro's. i just want there to be something inherent to the job that scares away bad players. i want players to HAVE to memorize the mudra combos.

About that.. how many bards have you seen that don't use songs? Mudra being hard will just mean level 50 rogues in ninja gear.

[Zoeila]

i want there to be something to scare away narutards before the term lolnin is coined.

[jomoru]

i want there to be something to scare away narutards before the term lolnin is coined.

People have been begging since the start to improve the quality of Dragoon. Lolnin is the only way

[ZReport]

i want there to be something to scare away narutards before the term lolnin is coined.

What are you talking about?

lolnin was coined as soon as Ninja was announced. You obviously don't understand just how popular ninja are.

[Firepower]

I don't see how a macro for ninja (assuming the 3 skills combined to create the desired effect can be macroed to an equal or faster time than manually) Can be a bad thing.

The only disadvantage I can imagine is if you have 5 different mudras (I II III IV V VI) and you are going I II III for a certain effect but something happens on the battlefield where you are mid combo and decide to switch to I II IV which could be more effective for example an AOE when a bunch of adds pop like garuda's feathers. That seems to be entirely massively situational and judging at the speed they are used already would require really good timing.

In my opinion I would imagine macroing the mudra's would make perfect sense as you could have all the desired outcomes neatly organised to be used at will, even more so if they can be done with minimal wait times that could be quicker than human input.

[Zoeila]

I don't see how a macro for ninja (assuming the 3 skills combined to create the desired effect can be macroed to an equal or faster time than manually) Can be a bad thing.

its bad because it would let people bypass having to memorize them. and judging by the vitrol im getting im guessing a lot of people wanted to be lazy and do just that. i have no problem with general macro use but this is different.

edit:even though its not possible, to me it would be like a monk macroing thier entire rotation instead of memorizing it and adjusting it on the fly.

[jomoru]

its bad because it would let people bypass having to memorize them. and judging by the vitrol im getting im guessing a lot of people wanted to be lazy and do just that. i have no problem with general macro use but this is different.

I'm not giving you vitrol. I'm saying making ninja super hard isn't going to make them an elite class among classes, its going to make them "lolnin"

[Moheeheeko]

edit:even though its not possible, to me it would be like a monk macroing thier entire rotation instead of memorizing it and adjusting it on the fly.

Protip: people do actually do this

[Eggnook24]

Fine, no more SCH macros. Hope you can wait to die before I finish finding my abilities on these 4 crossbars.

[Raxion]

I don't think harder combos is going to make the Job any less desirable to those who want to play it. The elitists will abandon the job when they find out that it can't compete with MNK DPS, and the "scrubs" will just play the job badly. I'm calling it now, NIN is going to be the next loldrg.