It's kind of... weird... to make this about being a good SCH or a bad SCH. Remembering to tie my shoes every morning does not make me a great runner, forgetting to tie my shoes in the morning doesn't even make me a bad runner - though it might mean the next sprint will be my last for a few days - but it has nothing to do with the skill of running. Some people just have better short term memory than others.

Hell, "the absent minded professor" is a thing because spontaneous memory has little to do with skill or intelligence.

I think this would be a nice change, it doesn't really effect the overall flow of the game, but removes one of those little niggling annoyances.