Honest question: If every player/class/job is equal,who is unique? (Gameplay topic)

[Pantz]

You're once again assuming EVERYONE will have the same expectations for a certain fight. You can't read the minds of the over 10k players out there and assume each and everyone of them DEMAND a certain class. No one is forcing them. They have the choice, if they choose not to, then they choose not to. SE didn't twist their arm and say "HEY! LEVEL THIS OR YOU CAN'T GET IN HERE!" They can simply enter with their preferred class and run the dungeon with a group who wants their class/job and there will always be people who will prefer the PLD to the WAR and Vise versa.

You mean that Ramuh pet tank fiasco wasn't telling enough? If people have a way to make a fight easy by excluding a class and requiring another class, you can be sure people are going to enforce it.

I have played enough MMOs to know that if a fight favours a certain class and disadvantages another class, 99% of people are going to enfocre class restrictions, because it makes things easier.

[Scootaloo]

You mean that Ramuh pet tank fiasco wasn't telling enough? If people have a way to make a fight easy by excluding a class and requiring another class, you can be sure people are going to enforce it.

You're relying on assumptions to back up your points and I fail to see how that makes your statement fact.

You can't assume everyone is going to play copycat and REQUIRE the same party line up nor can you assume players will prefer one class over another just because they have a skill that makes them unique.