Scylla's Robe of Healing or Daystar Robe? (WHM)

[EricCartmenez]

I have both, and I'm pretty sure the answer will be, "depends on what you want to do."

Daystar Robe (iLVL 110):
Vitality 41
Mind 39
Accuracy 8
Critical Hit Rate 29
Piety 31

Scylla's Robe (iLVL 100):
Vitality 35
Mind 34
Accuracy 8
Determination 19
Spell Speed 38

The obvious differences here are in the inclusion/exclusion of the last two attributes as well as the item levels. My MP and HP are a lot higher with the inclusion of the Daystar Robe, but I see more people with Scylla's Robe. Seems the Daystar Robe is better for those times when you have to do some DPS but Scylla's is for those healing intense moments. I would think that it would be worth the iLVL drop to use Scylla's Robe for situations where healing and a scholar is available and the Daystar Robe is right for battles when I have to help burn down items.

It's hard to see that drop of about HP, MP, and iLVL when I don Scylla's Robe, you know? A bit of a blow to the ego.