Craftsmanship vs. Magic Craftsmanship

[Jet]

Assumption I have read is that its divided between the crystals/shards the recipe needs:

Fire, Wind, Earth: Craftmanship
Lightning, Ice, Water: Magic Craftmanship

I really don't think so. Entire crafts are based mostly on one or two elements (BSM for example is primarily fire and wind), so your theory would mean that BSM is based on Craftsmanship, even though M. Craftsmanship gear is available for it. This doesn't make sense from a game design standpoint.

The ones that I know of:
Magical:
Dyed Cloths (Weaver)
Powders (Alchemist)

Physical:
Shards from Fish (Alchemist)

...I did a couple hundred Black Sole synths starting at 31 to come to this conclusion.

Thanks for some concrete examples.

Many items in this game are tiered so if you figure out what stat to use on an item, theres a really good chance that the rest of the same type of item use the same stat. For example, all wands use Magic Craftsmanship, all lumber uses Craftsmanship.

More concrete examples. Thanks. Also good insight about entire types of items using craft/m. craft.

Figuring out what tool is more logical in making a particular item seems to be a decent hint too...

This seems very subjective. Is it really more logical to think that wands are better made with hammers than with saws? Maybe, but does SE think that we all should know this sort of "logic"?

Thanks, everyone, for trying to help me out on this topic.

If any of you are willing, it would probably be useful to a lot of people if we kept the thread alive and just post item types that we've tested/confirmed to be craftsmanship/m. craftsmanship.