I am against the suggestion of OP. Lots of players get carried by their friends, guild or luck and they get the clear, these players can also ruin a farm/kill run. Its wrong to assume that every newcomer is terrible scrub and that every player who has done it once is epic awsome bassass. I reckon if you want to farm, go with friends and freecompany members and if you get a random that is bad, kick him or her out.

This thread reminds me alot of World of Warcraft that game is known for its community segregation and vile cesspool that drives newcomers away from clearing content. FFXIV does not have the best community, but we are much better then WoW, please dont encourage players to become World of Warcraft community 2.0.