Yes of course the accuracy is wasted when you're over capped with Omelettes...That's why you don't go over cap and use the food to REACH cap, thats why when I applied the theoretical int to the omelettes, I just assumed it allowed for more crit because this way, if it was still over the amount of theoretical int, it would absolutely be better. Contrary to your post's assumption I did apply the new stat weights posted a while back where Spell Speed (.27) and Det (.246) are higher than Crit (.209), and Omelettes STILL came out ahead just due to them giving more stats overall. Lyrica's point is valid, Sachs are almost impossible to make full use out of, and while even BiS BLM aren't making full use out of Omelettes they are still getting more stats than they would with sach. Even applying the stat weights to what stats they gain Omelettes come out ahead.


Don't just assume and read the post carefully, I mentioned I applied the CURRENT PURO STAT WEIGHTS to find the theoretical int for each food AND in the case where I needed a theoretical int value for accuracy, I even assumed worst case scenario and applied those points to crit, assuming the extra accuracy translated to more crit on gear, and even then it came out ahead.

I know it basically sounds like I just said the same thing twice, but twice now you seem to have missed the point in each of my posts. Also as a final note I'm not saying you should "rely on Foes Req" for your parses. That was for the OP who was asking whether or not their DPS was good enough. It was part of a question, justified by how much numbers can swell depending on its uptime, to the OP, as a way of marking whether they were doing enough. As in, check how much your bard Foes, that could be why you're only seeing 360 and not higher. Not some profound statement about the nature of Black Mages and their dependency on the # of bards in a party.