R50 Weapons: Halberd vs Lance vs Guisarme

[Budi]

Has anyone compared/tested the four r50 weapons yet?

Iron Halberd (+1)
Accuracy: 150 (157)
Attack: 169 (177)
Critical: 142 (149)

Lominsan Halberd
Accuracy: 151
Attack: 172
Critical: 143
Attributes: + 20HP, + 3STR

Champion's Lance (+1)
Accuracy: 135 (141)
Attack: 177 (186)
Critical: 146 (153)

Canopus Guisarm
Accuracy: 146
Attack: 176
Critical: 136
Attributes: + 2PIE, + 3DEX, +4EVA

[origamikitsune]

Currently I am using the Lominsian Halberd. I'll be switching to Canopus Guisarm if I ever get it. Its still not as good as the Champions +3 through (which will have about 145 acc, 203 atk, 167 Crit). That seems to be the general trend with the new drops / rewards - They are as good as the crafted items +1 or +2, but not as good as the +3. The advantage that Canopus has is the 70% Piercing, 20% Bashing, 10% Slashing, where as the Champion's Lance is 100% Piercing. Mostly this lets you put out more damage against things like undead, which are susceptible to bashing damage. Canopus also has the +3dex and +3eva, the former of which is great for a dex build LNC (which I prefer - for fights like the Ogre, hitting your WS to stun his is more important than shelling out large amounts of damage, IMO).

Really, it comes down to play style. Are you more interested in damage output? Go with the Champions +3. Are you more interested in hitting? Canopus is the way to go.

[Amineri]

Currently I am using the Lominsian Halberd. I'll be switching to Canopus Guisarm if I ever get it. Its still not as good as the Champions +3 through (which will have about 145 acc, 203 atk, 167 Crit). That seems to be the general trend with the new drops / rewards - They are as good as the crafted items +1 or +2, but not as good as the +3. The advantage that Canopus has is the 70% Piercing, 20% Bashing, 10% Slashing, where as the Champion's Lance is 100% Piercing. Mostly this lets you put out more damage against things like undead, which are susceptible to bashing damage. Canopus also has the +3dex and +3eva, the former of which is great for a dex build LNC (which I prefer - for fights like the Ogre, hitting your WS to stun his is more important than shelling out large amounts of damage, IMO).

Really, it comes down to play style. Are you more interested in damage output? Go with the Champions +3. Are you more interested in hitting? Canopus is the way to go.

I'm not sure how you can say go with Canopus if you like hitting stuff. Even an NQ Iron Halberd has better accuracy then Canopus (150 vs 146). My Iron Halberd +2 gives me a base 165 accuracy, which beats even a +3 Champion's Lance for accuracy (which has only 156).

I personally prefer hitting things, so I've gone with the Iron Halberd.

[Krausus]

I'm not sure how you can say go with Canopus if you like hitting stuff. Even an NQ Iron Halberd has better accuracy then Canopus (150 vs 146). My Iron Halberd +2 gives me a base 165 accuracy, which beats even a +3 Champion's Lance for accuracy (which has only 156).

I personally prefer hitting things, so I've gone with the Iron Halberd.

with 1.18 hitting things is no longer an issue.

[Alaltus]

I dont have the drive right now to go the extra mile for a better weapon since the effect most likely wont even be noticeable and will probbably be replaced in not too long down the line. So i chose to go the cheap route and just bought an iron halberd in preparation of my final rank up. Hitting wise the HQ Iron halberd wins but im sure its quite expensive just like a hq champions lance.

[NoxAlexzander]

Well i have a Champions Lancer +1 and i dont seem to have much problem anymore with Missing all the time i think they Fixed it now SO i would like to have Canopus Guisarm for mobs like undead and stuff that isnt good for Piercing damage.. But all in All the Champions Will be my main weapon for now still has best Att and Crit...

[Irana]

How come you didnt list the banneret lance +1? XD

[Scape]

I prefer Banneret over Halberd.

And for the most part, for all the new weapons for all classes, they are only better if you don't have +2 or 3 of the other weapons. They almost kinda even at +1 as well.

[RegaDosei]

Canopus has +10 style....so I'm going to have to say my canopus!
http://tinyurl.com/3l8uzs9

[Alcide]

Got my Canopus yesterday and I really think it's just for show... of all the r50 weapons we've got it has the worst attributes (also I thinks it's really awfull, but well it's still a Batraal drop, i'm gonna use it to show off ù.ù).

If you've got only nq weapons, IMHO Lominsan is the best one, it's got less attack and crit than Champion's, but the difference is quite little compared to the difference in accuracy. And yes, I happen to miss and during BR it's really annoying >.>

Btw, the Piety on Canopus is really bugging me, what the hell is it for? o.O