Mapping out Chocobo Dye

[Alinah]

Would 1 pear from Abyssal Blue put me there or is that under the assumption I make it back to Wine?

The colors I've gone now most recently have been

Deepwood Green (added 2 Plum 2 Pineapple 1 Valfruit) --> Regal Purple (added 2 Plum 6 Pineapple 9 Valfruit) --> Rolanberry Red (added 5 Pears) --> Wine Red (added 5 Plum 3 Valfruit based off a simulator) --> Abyssal Blue

Well if you're abyssal blue atm try apple (only), wait for the grow new feathers message. You should be at Rolanberry Red.
Then feed Pear (only), see where you end up if you end up at wine again, then we know that wine is the middle color between rolanberry red and grape purple. Looking at it though, it would make ALOT of sence if it was.

I'ld suggest you stop feeding it so many different foods aswell, take the time. It's easier to get to the wanted color if you know where you are on the map. Specially when you're so close.

[Ravenloft]

Well if you're abyssal blue atm try apple (only), wait for the grow new feathers message. You should be at Rolanberry Red.
Then feed Pear (only), see where you end up if you end up at wine again, then we know that wine is the middle color between rolanberry red and grape purple. Looking at it though, it would make ALOT of sence if it was.

I'ld suggest you stop feeding it so many different foods aswell, take the time. It's easier to get to the wanted color if you know where you are on the map. Specially when you're so close.

I tried to help him before, but he's taking the advice of people in the "Chaos Thread" which means feeding multiple types of fruit in one session. Which I just cannot agree with on something like this or almost any other time. Yours kills two birds with one stone, better chance for him to get grape and more confirmation on where the heck wine red is.

Edit: Seems like someone in the Chaos Thread has some kind of calculator/simulator for choco colors going on. I know this is mean, and I'm sorry, but I just find that to be lol funny. You can't really effectively "Calculate" something to that level that has RNG in it. It's just a fancier way of "counting fruit" to a certain color. And how did that work out?.. -.-

[Zaes]

I tried to help him before, but he's taking the advice of people in the "Chaos Thread" which means feeding multiple types of fruit in one session. Which I just cannot agree with on something like this or almost any other time. Yours kills two birds with one stone, better chance for him to get grape and more confirmation on where the heck wine red is.

For the first 8 feedings I was following the "feather message" one type of fruit feeding and was not only getting random colors that were listed differently or not listed at all but also got stuck in a 24 hour loop of Regal Purple and Royal Blue. I tried feeding multiple fruits because plenty of other people were coming up with stuff close or exactly what they were looking for.

It's not that I don't want to listen, it's just that neither thing was producing results similar to other people doing either method so really I'm just at a loss as to why this color is being much more of a bother to get then a lot of the others.

If you feel like mapping out for me where to go from Loam Brown I'm all for it because that's where I'm stuck at now.