Quote Originally Posted by Percyphanie View Post
I really, really think people need to stop using the existing spreadsheet and start a new one that reflects the number of fruits that gave the 'growing new feathers' message. then if we can duplicate those results we know we have a winning formula.

These multiple colors from the same recipe obviously isn't the answer.
Yup, it sounds like only the fruits that give a message matter. Maybe there's some RNG to it and those who don't give a message have no impact on the chocobo's colour at all.