Well that's kinda silly. How can one police a vote kick system if the rules on vote kicking aren't cut and dry? The rules should state "If you are kicked for a reason that does not fit with the option selected for why you were kicked, then that is a violation of our vote kick abuse policy and will be investigated."

I have only ever had to vote kick players for one of the first three options ever. Plenty of folks who have gone AFK in Labyrinth or ST, plenty of folks who go offline for more than 2-3 minutes, and at least one instance of being referred to by an array of derogatory slurs. Never really saw cheating anywhere in my travels, but I know it does exist.

If you are not being kicked due to being AFK, for going Offline, for harassment of another player, or for cheating, there is no reason that you should be kicked and the reason why you were actually kicked should be investigated. I mean, it sounds to me as though either the GM was either being lazy or they have a more stringent set of criteria for judging what is and is not an infringement of the vote kick system that we, the players, have not been told.