Quote Originally Posted by Raze View Post
Peregrine I usually agree with you but in this case I'd have to point out that a THM will find themselves in a tough fight when facing purely physical mobs. I have yet to see emulate work on buffalo, uraeus(even breath), or mosshorn and his clan. I don't know if you think they are still viable prospects once emulate is out of the picture but they'll be spamhealing themselves quite a bit and even with throwing out whatever damage they can while holding hate, they'll still need additional healing every once in a while (depending on NM) yada yada yada So my point is.... I think you have a solid bet getting whatever SE decides to "call" a tank, GLA,MRD,PGL.... they all work, fresh out of the box!

I have watched a THM tank Mosshorn just fine, he only did it because of a freak death of the tank but it worked out well enough, I would never go into a fight with the expectations of a THM tanking though. Though I agree with you that THM should not be on the list of "better" tank, just on the list of "able".