Quote Originally Posted by ServerCollaps View Post
if they require pop conditions why does hunt scholars tell you different things about "popping" them in different languages settings? Rank A+ B mobbs also have "pop conditions" told by hunt scholars but they just repop after x amount of time, i think its just the same with S ranks.

There are always ppl walking with their pets to summon nandi, hundreds without success or hundreds of players jumping off cliffs to summon safrat, douzens of ppl cooking in central thanalan without success, hundreds of ppl doing the northern thanalan fate multiple times without seeing the S rank. There are 24/7 ppl who try to trigger sth and when an S pops (just by random) the one out of 100 guys without success really thinks he triggered it
This is very true. A lot of the members of my LS on Excalibur think S ranks are timed spawns just like A & B.