How do you decide commendations?

[Bouldergore]

If mobs are going and attacking everyone, then the tank failed.
if everyone is doing their job but the healer goes OOM then the DPS failed.
if the tank dies or a dps dies while the tank is at full health and the healer has mana then healer failed.

there are of course exceptions but in a nut shell this is a decent way to tell who isnt pulling their weight.

[MilesSaintboroguh]

If mobs are going and attacking everyone, then the tank failed.
if everyone is doing their job but the healer goes OOM then the DPS failed.
if the tank dies or a dps dies while the tank is at full health and the healer has mana then healer failed.

there are of course exceptions but in a nut shell this is a decent way to tell who isnt pulling their weight.

You consider those failures even if it happened just once? I usually let screws ups slide unless it happens more than once.

[Zoberraz]

if the tank dies or a dps dies while the tank is at full health and the healer has mana then healer failed.

Isn't that a little contradictory? The tank can't be at full health and dead at the same time. x_x