Ordered in heirachy. A always gets it over the rest, for example.

A) Friendliness towards the party - This is my biggest one. I hate toxicity in the community, and will commend anyone who is acting friendly towards the party.
This includes helping new players and explaining fights.
I'm friendly in every group I join, I like to see other players acting the same way

B) Excellent demonstrations of skill

C) Those that pull off something truly amazing.
Healer surviving Hellfire in Ifrit Hard and using the LB to res everyone comes to mind.

D) Finding a fellow DRG who actually knows what they're doing.
Frustrates me when 80% of them don't even know what Heavy Thrust is :|