The truth is that PLD is not able to add as much to raid / full party group as WAR. He is able to tank pretty well, but all he has to do is just click on cooldowns whenever they are needed. As OT, PLD cannot be even compared to what WAR is able to do. Square Enix did good work reworking WAR but they made him a great (sometimes much better than PLD) MT and best OT you can search for. Honestly, WAR/WAR is always better than PLD/PLD.

PLD should have some way to deal more damage, for example add additional Potency to the RoH combo when used with Sword Oath. At this point PLD as MT is doing the same as OT. Spam RoH for str debuff and most damage, oh and sometimes cast Stone Skin. I have experienced people that were whining about me (as PLD) being OT because I'm just a filler who does completely nothing. And they are right. I'm doing way too low damage to be any kind of help as OT. And I'm not blaming them for selecting WAR as MT. He can generate more enmity per gcd and can self heal quite a lot. Also he does more damage.

Rework is needed, indeed. We have too many CDs and too low actives.