Possible Paladin Rework...

[Daniolaut]

stuff all the time only stuff

Kitru do you even play FFXIV? All i ever see you doing on the forums is -attempting- to prove people wrong. Seriously

I did an HIJKLMNOP test and put my CDEFG on and added WTFDOUEVENFFXIV to my PLD and WAR and here are my results, you CANNOT argue these numbers so go away. (i70 giantsgall nq from skirmish in 1.0 on war vs i70+i100 {sword shield})

PICTURES so you cant get confused!!

This Paladin in shield oath!






This is Warrior in Defiance!




Same character! same gear! except PLD has better gear seeing as the shield is i100

WAR was about 1/6 crit hits where as PLD was 1/10 or so. Roughly I'm not going to spend all day hitting a freaking dummy to prove a point. (Auto attack was included in these ratios.)

I even made sure to include the auto attack.

Also both PLD and WAR are 30 points in vit. WAR's gain an automatic str bonus over PLD.

So non refutable WAR deals more damage thus gains more enmity over PLD. Thanks

What now??


Edit: i100 shield oops.

Note:

Your conversation with Giantbane is also ridiculous. this statement:

"It's getting kind of old to see PLDs whinging on about Flash and about how amazing Overpower is when they're completely ignoring the fact that Overpower is expensive as hell which is *why* it's so strong."

Is absurd. I cant think of a single pull in this entire game where the length a PLD can flash in relation to a WAR using overpower would lose threat because of loss of TP where a PLD would eventually win the threat race.

Flash is trash and needs to be on par with Overpower's threat generation. Never, ever, ever will PLD win a threat race where there are dps actually attacking the mobs.. that statement is absurd beyond absurdity.