Get Atma for just auto-attacking.

[Xmbei]

As a scholar I disagree, at times the only way I can ever remotely get gold is dot all mobs that spawn and most die quicker than my cast spells can allow. So I stand there bio everything I can hoping to get it before it dies and heal npcs and people tanking. If I only concentrate on a single mob at a time and not dot like made i get at best a silver but most times a bronze. Because melee kill things to quickly or my bio kills the mob in 3-4 tics. If they changed that system healers will have trouble in a lot of zones to get their gold status/atma. While NM fates I can actually do more things like heal, dot, and cast, so just because it may appear bad, some people have to do somethings just to get gold due to dps burns in atma fate areas.

Edit also the system is already on a semi contribution level for rankings. If i just healed I may get silver because I didnt aid in killing the monster I just sat there healing. But if I heal and do some damage most of time more than a few % you can get gold. But I digress if they changed the system dont expect atma to get better. Some people are there for 6+ hours and dont care to try super hard but want to beat the rng. So they are so tired and mind numb that they will do bare minimum to get gold. While if you are fresh their you might be pissed, but think that after days of 1 area atma farming you learn to effiecently use your time just to get gold and get pissed when some fresh body wants to pk you for just being worn down by the grind.