
Originally Posted by
Jabo
1. So you are telling me it is easy to take on a 57 Raptor as a 45 LNC?
Ummm, no, are you even reading my post or the post I am replying too? I am talling you a 45 LNC can do it just as easy as a 45 CON
Not talking impossible here or whatnot. Just easy vs hard.
You are even talking about the same amount of mobs. So i would gladly see a LNC or MRD defeat easily 3 Raptors at the same time.
I would gladly like to see a CON do it too, its not any easier for one over the other, thats my point.
2. Melees have TP restrictions for their healing skills. So what, mages have MP restriction, they heal and damage off the same pool of MP
3. Mages can use Second Wind too, which only leaves Bloodbath. Again, so what, mellee can use cure I, II, and II as well as sacrafice I, II, and III. It works both ways.
And you think Bloodbath is better for healing then Sacrifice II or III or Cure II and III. Really? Where did I say this? please show me.
An attack which can only be used every 50s+, an attack where you need to sync it with your strongest weaponskill to be even slightly comparable to Tier II healing spells, and if you miss, you don't get healed in an often close situation.
Mages have also Aegis Boom, which is a mostly a free 500HP. Without the need or TP or MP. Requires a shield for that does it not? You now have proof that every mage in this game uses a shield at all times to back that up I assume?
4. Healing spells on other classes are much weaker and their your have your MP restrictions because they have 1/3 the MP and they cannot refill 50% of it every 10min.
Mages can use Bloodbath and Second Wind, too. Second Wind without any restrictions. Again, so what, mages only have 1/3 the def/HP if thats the case, thus by your standards having need to heal 2/3 more..... every spell/ws you mentioned can be used by all classes except bloodbath and all classes have MP/TP restrictions to there heals.
5. There are so obvious reasons why mages simply can take a lot more enemies at the same time. Assuming you are attacked by 8 enemies 10 ranks above you. I call bull on this. show me mages regularly doing this...I know I never said they could.
PUG, LNC, MRD, ARC get 150dmg per hit = 1200dmg every 5-10s
THM, CON, GLA get healed every hit for 50HP = 400HP healed every 5-10s
^^^This part doesn't even make relavent sense. All you do is show how one is out putting damage and speculating how another is healing.........how much damage per hit is a mage taking VS a MRD ? MRD can AoE damage as well. Mages will burn MP trying to heal and never do damage....end result is the same.
just in the first seconds.
PUG, LNC, MRD, ARC and GLA have to hit one mob now, till they have their 1000/2000tp, before they can land one single AoE weapon skill they already took 2500-3500 DMG.
The Mages have ~20s Aegis Boom up, which allows you to cast 10 AoE Spells with comparable damage.
So in these first 20s DoW classes took 3500dmg and had 1-2 Aoe attack were Mages got healed for 1000HP and did 10 AoE attacks.
You are also safe for the next 20s if you have Sentinel.
So in 40s it would be 7000DMG and 2-4 AoE Attacks vs 1000HP healed and 20 AoE attacks.
And I'm not playing my DoW classes wrong, if i simply can not heal myself against 8 enemies instead of getting 5000DMG in 30-60s, because i simply can not.
And I'm not playing it wrong because i simply don't have a powerful AoE attack which i can spam every 2s. Because thats the lowest auto-attack timer of every melee class on one single, low damage attack. I simply don't have the skills.
If your not playing it wrong then your talking out your backside about mages, which was the other option I gave, again, your only reading what you want and recalling what you want.. I doubt you have attempted 8 mobs that are 10 levels higher on both or you would have agreed with my previous post about how easily mages would get plowed as they have limited defence.........Not to mention second wind has just as diminishing effects for mages as cure does for DoW. My issue here is that you say one thing applies one way, and convieniently ignore it does the other way as well.