Quote Originally Posted by Karnyboy View Post
SNIP
If you want to need on an item, come as that class. Simple as that.

Unless you checked what classes the WHM has leveled (which you obviously didn't) you would have known instantly if they could use it for leveling, and its highly likely he did need it for that; the other possibility is he wanted it for Glamour, as that robe is one of the better-looking ones in the game.
Third option? GC Turn-Ins. Seals are Valuable, and if that's all he wanted the robe for its perfectly fine for him to do so. If there are no leveling casters in the group when I'm healing a lowbie dungeon, I will Need on all caster/healer loot to turn in for seals, otherwise I Greed on it (and still win 90% of the time).

Its also obvious you didn't say anything to the WHM about needing the robe for an alt. No right to complain, IMO, if you can't be bothered to type a few words before rolling.