NINJA and ROGUE confirmed

[LoLo]

It's understandable WHY you're doing it. But you're asking them to implement something that requires them to completely rework the lore, history, story and backgrounds that they already have made. The same sex marriage is only a matter of allowing the eligible "members" number to increase.

You're basically bashing your head against a wall that won't break. At least when it comes to the name of "Thief". Like I mentioned before, they may very well add a Job down the line that will play like the Thief you so desperately want, but be named something else.

It was a weak excuse to say that Thief can not fit into the lore. It is totally possible to fit Thief in without going against the lore because currently there are killers, scammers, people who sell sex, Pirates, Cults, rapist, Atmos which is a portal to a dark world, a nazi-like enemy that wants to kill all the Primals which act like selfish Gods to the beastmen. There is no reason why Thief couldn't be added. Not only that it is simple to add Thief by just making a Thief job stem from Rogue. There is no proof yet that has convinced me that it is impossible to add a Thief Job.

[Abraxis]

Not only that it is simple to add Thief by just making a Thief job stem from Rogue.

So you want them to add a Job from a Class that "moved on" from being the Job that they "moved on" from?

There is no proof yet that has convinced me that it is impossible to add a Thief Job.

You mean other than the fact that the man that rebuilt the game, basically from the ground up, saying "No Thief"?

Not at all, rogues come from thiefs, thief job comes from a rogue rogue using a thief soul stone

So if they go from Thief to a Rogue, and then back to Thief...what's the point of Rogue in the first place?

[LoLo]

So you want them to add a Job from a Class that "moved on" from being the Job that they "moved on" from?

Proof of this please?

You mean other than the fact that the man that rebuilt the game, basically from the ground up, saying "No Thief"?

Proof of this please?

Also that same man you described said he wasn't putting in same sex marriage but its coming now. So he can change his mind. People who get mad at others who want something changed in the game are just defending the game because to them the devs can do no wrong. That attitude is hindering the games progress.

[Abraxis]

Proof of this please?

Did you not bother watching the Live letter? I mean...at all?

Here, I didn't want to bother doing all the work for you but i'll oblige. Evolved from thieves. Watch at least the next 10 minutes of it as well. They expand on it even more and "...why would a city even allow something like that..."

Proof of this please? Also that same man you described said he wasn't putting in same sex marriage but its coming now. So he can change his mind. People who get mad at others who want something changed in the game are just defending the game because to them the devs can do no wrong. That attitude is hindering the games progress.

And Yoshida NEVER said outright "nope, no gay marriage". I'll even post the quote and link

First we would like to start out with opposite-sex marriage, and then consider the feedback from our players in order to make a careful decision. I can't say whether or not it will be possible at this point in time.

The rest of the Q and A is here. You'll have to scroll down a bit, or just Ctrl+F and search for "Marriage". So it was specifically stated that they WOULD listen to player feedback and go from there. So they're doing EXACTLY what you want them to. They're listening to players before making a final decision.

He never actually said 'no thief'... he said 'no thieves guild' which is an entirely different thing. Nowhere at all has it been stated that a Thief job could not happen.

True, i'll give you that. But why would they specifically state that Rogues WERE Theives, only to revert back to what they came FROM?

[LoLo]

Did you not bother watching the Live letter? I mean...at all?

Here, I didn't want to bother doing all the work for you but i'll oblige. Evolved from thieves. Watch at least the next 10 minutes of it as well. They expand on it even more and "...why would a city even allow something like that..."




And Yoshida NEVER said outright "nope, no gay marriage". I'll even post the quote and link

Because Rogue came from Thief you want me to believe its impossible to add? Sorry but that isn't enough proof for me to believe anything you are saying. I will continue to ask for a Thief Job until Yoshi P saids "No plans to add a Thief Job ever."

[Abraxis]

Because Rogue came from Thief you want me to believe its impossible to add? Sorry but that isn't enough proof for me to believe anything you are saying. I will continue to ask for a Thief Job until Yoshi P saids "No plans to add a Thief Job ever."

...Right. I've tried, i added links, quotes, video to support what i'm saying and you REFUSE to see reason. You're so fanatical about this that you're too close minded to even bother continuing this..."conversation" isn't even the right word.

[LoLo]

...Right. I've tried, i added links, quotes, video to support what i'm saying and you REFUSE to see reason. You're so fanatical about this that you're too close minded to even bother continuing this..."conversation" isn't even the right word.

First that quote said that Thieves do exist in the lore, but you sat and said everything would have to be reworked to even add Thief into the lore. Secondly the quote only saids that Rogues used to be Thieves. The key word here is "used" so then that means they are no Thieves anymore. They are a different thing than a Thief. Your quote actually supports more reason why Thief job should be in the game. Your evidence back fired which is why I won't believe your negative comments.

Secondly everyone or how about almost everyone has seen that "provided" video. There is nothing proving or backing up your weak points. Continue to look like a broken record though, no one is stopping you.

[Alberel]

True, i'll give you that. But why would they specifically state that Rogues WERE Theives, only to revert back to what they came FROM?

Probably because all of the guilds in Limsa evolved from illegal pirate organisations that had to drop the darker parts of their heritage in order to be a part of the city state.

Remember also that whilst joining a guild makes you one of many in the story, taking up a job is unique to the player in the lore. So the player would simply become a rogue then explore the guild's darker history and rediscover the thief skills... the rest of the rogue's guild would still be rogues.

[Alberel]

You mean other than the fact that the man that rebuilt the game, basically from the ground up, saying "No Thief"?

He never actually said 'no thief'... he said 'no thieves guild' which is an entirely different thing. Nowhere at all has it been stated that a Thief job could not happen.

[Jandor]

So if they go from Thief to a Rogue, and then back to Thief...what's the point of Rogue in the first place?

They became Rogues because no one wanted a bunch of Thieves hanging around, however after all this time they find they need to make use of those neglected thievery skills from their shady past in order to help the realm. Enter the player character, who will track down one of the last surviving members of the old order of thiefs who refused to join in setting up the Rogues guild, he teaches you the lost art of stealing stuff and together you infilitrate a Garlean base, steal some important stuff and save Eorzea.

Ask me a hard one .