Details about Server issues

[Raist]

Edit:
Misread previous post, and responded in error. Amended the post slightly and left it up, as it was mostly to clarify the points about restrictive access to Canada, and how a seemingly minor hiccup along a route for one person can indicate a big problem for many in the scope of FFXIV.

There are a small handful of ISP's providing access to Canada, and they basically "lease" that access out to our ISP's so that we can connect to servers in Canada. This happens all over the place. If not, we would not be able to load webpages or send email to anyone not on our ISP's own network. You may not even be able to contact people with the same ISP if they were in a disparate region--you would only be able to connect to the people on the localized network.

What this means is that if Level3's routers are overloaded/stalled/taken offline, everyone who is stuck with them as their routing partner to the region managed by those routers---their access to that region becomes compromised. This is what has been happening for YEARS. It isn't a phenomenon isolated to just XIV.

Perhaps some visuals will help demonstrate the issue better:

Cogent Communications Network Map:


Take a very close look at how their trunks access Montreal from the US (can right-click the picture and "View Image", then you can zoom in and such, as it is a higher res picture than displayed in the forum).

They basically have 3 paths... let me restate that: THREE paths that feed into Canada for getting to Montreal: Two from the East, and one from the West. That means for the US, you are coming through the New York/Massachusetts, or Washington state corridors. Unfortunately, California is routinely congested on it's own, and then you can get bogged down again coming around the WA/BC corridor even further. It doesn't matter where you are coming from in the US if your ISP has partnered with Cogent to carry your data to Montreal--you basically have those 3 paths to take to get into Canada. If there are issues along one of those limited paths, everyone using that path gets screwed at once. SE has absolutely NO control over that---that is between Cogent Communication because it is their network hardware in play, and your ISP because THEY have chosen to route you across Cogent's hardware.

Now, here is a link to Level3's map, the ISP in question from the OP:
http://maps.level3.com/default/#.U5UPHig2lW8

Just take a moment to zoom in on Montreal and look at how things get routed there via Level3's network. Guess what? It's once again NEW YORK AND MASSACHUSETTS for the US entry points if you are on their network. They don't show an entry point for the Vancouver area. It's only via the North East.

And now, here's TATA's map:


That image is hard to discern, but they basically have the same access as Cogent--one corridor for the west, two for the east. There is a link to a PDF you can load if you want to see things more clearly.

These are three of the big players up there, and who almost all of us ultimately wind up dealing with in order to get to Ormuco, who is SE's ISP in Montreal. Now, compound this with how everyone is partnered with everyone else to get us over there. For example, i-web is partnered with all three of them:

http://iweb.com/reliable-hosting
(Network Partners logos, down near bottom of the page)

Likewise, our ISP's partner with multiple other routing partners to build routes to get us to where ever we want to go on the internet. You may find you hop off and on to multiple ISP's segments to finally reach your final destination. These routes are purchased by your ISP in some fashion or another (often times it is a quid-pro-quo arrangement and not actually paid for, but an agreement IS made with your ISP for access to the route). So, when there is a problem along such routes... it falls to your ISP to investigate and resolve the issue on your behalf. Either they get their partner to fix the problem, or they switch us to an alternate route (sometimes this requires a reboot of our modem as they may need to change our modem's config). Square-Enix has no responsibility, not to mention little to no influence, to address such issues unless it is shown to be an issue with their ISP (Ormuco) or their own network.