Something is seriously wrong

[Tigerclaw]

Problem is the dungeons do have a reasonable ilvl requirement. That said, you may need to balance cooldowns and or cc to manage a pull. The problem is a lot of people want to just run fast to complete so they either go too big and die to inability to heal thru, or they end up blaming party members who realize that they need to tone it back. Ive had to change blm gear mid dungeon to balance tank gear before.

All comes down to gear does not equal skill or role knowledge.

Not all players with good gear are good players, but all good players have good gear, at least relative to the task at hand.