As I mentioned in the OP, I know what their reasoning is, I'm just saying it's a bit unreasonable. There's also a huge difference between fishing for a net loss (Current system), and the system FFXI had (Black Sole NPCing for 720 gil a piece). I just think fishing for an hour should involve going into profit somehow, and not losing gil through the teleport and repair cost. Not even getting into bait, since I try to use lures any time I can.