ATMA.... again

[Jekyll]

For the book fates you don't need gold. You do need them not to fail, however.

I'm pretty sure you need gold. This is not from personal experience as I always got gold, but from watching people shout "You need to get gold too?! FFFFFFFFUUUUUUUU...." after a Giant Seps.

[Zakalwe]

I'm pretty sure you need gold. This is not from personal experience as I always got gold, but from watching people shout "You need to get gold too?! FFFFFFFFUUUUUUUU...." after a Giant Seps.

Nope, don't need gold, only need to successfully complete it.

[Andres_Lonegrief]

I have a question. As far as understood,in order to obtain atmas you need to fight on Fates occuring in those particular areas listed in the quest log. Any of those fate will do, right? Still i have yet to see a single atma. Since I can't play long hours i know it might be just a matter of time, but i'm starting to think that i'm doing something wrong. I know you have to get a gold medal to drop atmas (and being medals yellow white and brown there's no way i can fail to recognize them). However the mechanics is still similar to lightning returns event and since i couldn't drop the parcel to accomplish also that quest i'm starting to fear i'm doing something wrong or else it might could be some kind of bug - what do you think?

[Merle]

Nope, don't need gold, only need to successfully complete it.

Nope, for Atma book fates YOU NEED GOLD. I got silver in a couple fates and didn't count as completed