Quote Originally Posted by ispano View Post
It's a little harder on some, like Scholar for example. Scholar needs like 5-6 Sand, not including the weapon, and roughly 2-3 Oil. Not saying we should get more drops either.
Yeap, certain classes need more like SCH which benefits more from the soldier stuff due to the delicious crit there, but there are also certain classes that requires less, such as BRD (technically 2 sands, chest and belt, weapons excluded since you excluded in your example), so the raid can distribute accordingly. Assuming your WHM goes for DET/PIE on the left hand side, technically the WHM only need 1 sand for the Daystar Breeches while the other 5 body pieces are High Allagan as BiS. So, that's where you could get your extra needed sands from.