FFXI had many grinds like the Atma. Mechanics like that are the reason I played and enjoyed it for so long. If FFXIV:ARR were to adopt more grind-like mechanics, it would increase the longevity of content by boatloads.

While I'm not the biggest fan of FATEs, I did thoroughly enjoy gathering my 12 Atma. While some people complain about the grind, I think mechanics like this are 100% healthy for the game overall. I sincerely hope the devs weren't deterred from putting more grind mechnics into the game based on the forum response.