Results 1 to 10 of 159

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player

    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Posts
    196
    Quote Originally Posted by danny52844 View Post
    [Removed by Moderator according to the FINAL FANTASY XIV FORUM Guidelines.]unless they plan to raise the cap by like 50 lvs every time ur just going to get cap within a few weeks thus making all the previous stuff obsolete while only making u have to wait 2 weeks to start doing the new stuff making it obsolete along with everything else 2 weeks later than it would if u just kept the lvs the same just instead this time ull only have the new end game to do not the old stuff

    [Removed by Moderator according to the FINAL FANTASY XIV FORUM Guidelines.]
    So if my rebuttals are so bad, then come up with some other reason why horizontal progression doesn't limit growth of the game.

    Another statement: You can add in new weapons/armor that doesn't negate the existing.
    Rebuttal: If you add in new weapons that are better, you just negated the old content anyways, and if you add in something that isn't better. Then why even get it? Your limited on inventory spaces anyways... With vertical progression, you will need these new weapons and armors, new recipes, new gathering locations/materials.

    The problem with horizontal progression, is you are limiting the game to potential growth. Horizontal can only go so wide before it must go vertical. If you wait too long to go vertical, you lose all the players who don't like to repeat the same content 1000 times, and then you lose all the people who did and feel like they accomplished something by having +1 STR items over everyone else. If you do the merit system like FFXI, you are negating old content anyways, its another form of vertical progression, except the fact that now those old Rank 75 things are now super easy because of those merits.

    People who had level 100 crafting after 1 year of the game, still had level 100 crafting after 7 years of the game. They were done crafting. With vertical progression, you can keep all players growing.

    Here is an idea on how to keep older content relative... make existing weapons/armors upgradable by new and existing items. Capped areas, and update the existing content with new expansions (rank increases).

    So list out all the pro's and con's for horizontal progression, and guaranteed that vertical progression pro's and con's will outweigh everything horizontal does (from a business perspective)
    (0)
    Last edited by Baccanale; 07-17-2011 at 09:15 AM. Reason: Quoting content that was edited by Moderator due to violation of Forum Guidelines.

  2. #2
    Player
    darkstarpoet1's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Posts
    3,305
    Character
    Darkstar Poet
    World
    Excalibur
    Main Class
    Carpenter Lv 60
    Quote Originally Posted by AuctionGirl View Post
    So if my rebuttals are so bad, then come up with some other reason why horizontal progression doesn't limit growth of the game.

    Another statement: You can add in new weapons/armor that doesn't negate the existing.
    Rebuttal: If you add in new weapons that are better, you just negated the old content anyways, and if you add in something that isn't better. Then why even get it? Your limited on inventory spaces anyways... With vertical progression, you will need these new weapons and armors, new recipes, new gathering locations/materials.

    The problem with horizontal progression, is you are limiting the game to potential growth. Horizontal can only go so wide before it must go vertical. If you wait too long to go vertical, you lose all the players who don't like to repeat the same content 1000 times, and then you lose all the people who did and feel like they accomplished something by having +1 STR items over everyone else. If you do the merit system like FFXI, you are negating old content anyways, its another form of vertical progression, except the fact that now those old Rank 75 things are now super easy because of those merits.

    People who had level 100 crafting after 1 year of the game, still had level 100 crafting after 7 years of the game. They were done crafting. With vertical progression, you can keep all players growing.

    Here is an idea on how to keep older content relative... make existing weapons/armors upgradable by new and existing items. Capped areas, and update the existing content with new expansions (rank increases).

    So list out all the pro's and con's for horizontal progression, and guaranteed that vertical progression pro's and con's will outweigh everything horizontal does (from a business perspective)
    what part is hard to understand that most people do not want true horizontal. i do not want it to stay at r50 forever, but i do not think a set time frame on when to increase caps ia a good way to keep players involved. yeah i would like to see the cap raised in a year or 2 by a few levels, but it should stay there for a while and not say a year or so later it increases again. that ruins the chances at any long term goals and becomes a constant grind throughout the lifetime of the game.

    grinding levels are not what will keep a person there long term. it is the content and it doesn't matter if it is at the same cap or higher cap, but things to do are what people need.
    (1)


    http://crystalknights.guildwork.com/

  3. #3
    Player
    weeble's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Posts
    1,231
    Character
    Titan Arum
    World
    Balmung
    Main Class
    Goldsmith Lv 50
    Quote Originally Posted by darkstarpoet1 View Post
    what part is hard to understand that most people do not want true horizontal. i do not want it to stay at r50 forever, but i do not think a set time frame on when to increase caps ia a good way to keep players involved. yeah i would like to see the cap raised in a year or 2 by a few levels, but it should stay there for a while and not say a year or so later it increases again. that ruins the chances at any long term goals and becomes a constant grind throughout the lifetime of the game.

    grinding levels are not what will keep a person there long term. it is the content and it doesn't matter if it is at the same cap or higher cap, but things to do are what people need.





    dynmaisis, sky, sea, enerjiah,bs,ks, limbus, nyzle, salvage, znm, nm, hnm, assault and whatever else i missed lol, this was all doable all week. i was doing all this in the same week, events pretty much everyday, some days 2-3events. weither u had to or not, or want to or not, you didn't have to do it all, but hell if no cap raise was the reason we had all this to do every week rather then just 1thing and logging out.

    i don't play wow but em don't they all log in twice a week to do a dungeon and log out again? i know casual players might like this cause they can quickly hit max and then log in twice a week and still feel like they are gaming. but being able to have a choice to do all these options even all on same day or 2 is where it's at without the cap raises.

    besides you really think se is gonna come out with sooooo much content that we won't be bored every month? they are already putting out content so slow that even full expansions won't keep a player not bored after a month, most people leveled half the classes and finished there crafting witch is the main part of time constraint inbetween content. granted content will eventually (what a year from now?) start comming out faster, but either way like i said lot of players are gonna still be waiting for content. and yeah i know i'm bout to get this one sentence craped on cause someone gonna say i still got lots to do, but anyway.
    (2)

  4. #4
    Player
    darkstarpoet1's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Posts
    3,305
    Character
    Darkstar Poet
    World
    Excalibur
    Main Class
    Carpenter Lv 60
    Quote Originally Posted by weeble View Post
    [/B]



    dynmaisis, sky, sea, enerjiah,bs,ks, limbus, nyzle, salvage, znm, nm, hnm, assault and whatever else i missed lol, this was all doable all week. i was doing all this in the same week, events pretty much everyday, some days 2-3events. weither u had to or not, or want to or not, you didn't have to do it all, but hell if no cap raise was the reason we had all this to do every week rather then just 1thing and logging out.

    i don't play wow but em don't they all log in twice a week to do a dungeon and log out again? i know casual players might like this cause they can quickly hit max and then log in twice a week and still feel like they are gaming. but being able to have a choice to do all these options even all on same day or 2 is where it's at without the cap raises.

    besides you really think se is gonna come out with sooooo much content that we won't be bored every month? they are already putting out content so slow that even full expansions won't keep a player not bored after a month, most people leveled half the classes and finished there crafting witch is the main part of time constraint inbetween content. granted content will eventually (what a year from now?) start comming out faster, but either way like i said lot of players are gonna still be waiting for content. and yeah i know i'm bout to get this one sentence craped on cause someone gonna say i still got lots to do, but anyway.
    i actually agree with you and you must have misunderstood what i was meaning. they kept saying that raising the cap is the only way to keep content fresh. i disagree and like i said content regardless of if it is for a 50 or for a 75 is new content.

    i figured eventually the cap would be raised to 75. i was figuring maybe 30 days to a year after the ps3 version gets released. i really figure the first big expansion will wait til then as well. with the first big expansion should come some long term goals and items. this would give people a reason to want to move past the cap and expand their character.

    i just feel since we all know 50 is a low starting point it will have to increase, but do not feel it should be done on a yearly or bi-yearly basis. i just feel the first increase should be a major one and that it should stay there until they have done everything they can to keep the content horizontal from there. after that point i can understand a move, but don not feel it should be a set time frame on making a move. personally, i only believe the cap was r50 at the start because they didn't want us getting too far ahead of their ps3 players, but didn't expect it to take a year and still no release on the horizon.


    i admit freely this is just going off feelings and i have no proof to back any of it up. i just wanted to actually explain what i meant.
    (1)


    http://crystalknights.guildwork.com/

Tags for this Thread