I can certainly see that being a possible outcome should my proposed fix be implemented. But it's one person's word against another. If the 2-6 are fair people, they can choose to see how things go to see if the instigator is correct. Although, if the person badmouthing the blacklisted were also an individual notoriously known for not being a superb player with game mechanics, it really wouldn't help his case anyway. Not especially when you yourself have such good rep with a mass majority of the server.