Very Very insightful post by all. Thank you for your time and debate. So judging from what has been said it seems that progression seems to point towards this:

1) Melee Gaskin - Weathered Gloam Brais (+2 Acc, +2 Det)
2) Tremor Earring of Striking - Weathered Gloam Earrings (+12 Acc, +6 Crit, - 11 Det)

Total Soldiery Tomes to spend: 1200