My first Atma took 14 hours, which finally dropped in N. Shroud. I then proceed to C. Thanalan, and sure enough it drops on my first fate there. Not sure if its some sick joke but this quest is seriously out of hand. I'm all for quests being challenging, time consuming, and maybe even a little bit of RNG, but the extent to which this quest is RNG'd is out of this world. There is a difference between challenging and gambling, and this quest makes it quite clear which of the two it chooses to determine success. I absolutely love the "lol play something else", the "theres other content in the game, do that", or the really good one "i got mine in this amount of time, just keep going and you will get it eventually". The last one sometimes isn't directed in a negative or trolling fashion, but it comes off all the same in text. If you have to defend a quest that is so popular by saying "Do something else, we have other stuff in the game", that is just proving the point of poor quest design.