Parry...

[Megido]

As Casper pointed out. A 20% dps increase on a paladin is still only about 20 dps, in a group of 4 dps, all of which should now pull no less than 200, that is adding 20 dps to about 1000 dps group total (counting both tanks) give or take a few points. This is a VERY small increase.

It doesnt really matter who does the damage. That 20 dps increase would probably take a single dps weeks to get. Everything is a small increase in this game so thats not a real good argument. That 20 dps could just help you skip a phase or get a kill without having to wait another 1-2 resets, or in case of a dps dying and getting weakness on a boss barely at farm, that extra dps might just make it a non issue.

@ above, i would never trade 1% DR for 1% dmg. No tank ever should. But the difference seems to be more in favor of dmg, comparatively to your statement.