Parry...

[Judge_Xero]

so since all the BiS lists I find on the interwebz are based off of Parry/Acc, I bring up two questions: Determination or Crit, and what IS a good BiS list depending other than a parry one?

For PLD who uses Sword Oath when tank swapping (boost to AA damage) the best choice is DET.
War would probably be Crit because of using the OT rotation while in Defiance.

[ZDamned]

For PLD who uses Sword Oath when tank swapping (boost to AA damage) the best choice is DET.
War would probably be Crit because of using the OT rotation while in Defiance.

First off, Paladins should ALWAYS be using Sword Oath while not tanking. End of Story. You post far too great a threat to the group with a spike in RoH Damage, an dyou sacrifice a Damage De-Buff, as well as DPS by just using Riot Blade. In Essence, you prolong the fight because of being lazy.
2nd, Going for Crit only is like asking for RNG instead of Consistency. If that's what you like, then OK... have fun with that.

Finally, you actually can't achieve numbers with any other set that are as high as the one I posted.

If you stat for just Crit, you can't actually Hit your Target with food on. You just don't get access to enough accuracy.
If you stat just for Determination, you actually lose out on determination, because you can't use Determination food. My list gives you +119 with food on, and it's over accuracy cap, but full on Determination gear after accuracy food (Which is required if you stat that way) if only at 117.
In both instances you drop at least 11 of the other stat, and with my list you maximize both after food, since my list also gives you a total of 518 accuracy without food.

Aaaah, my apologies. I read the thread a few days ago and decided to comment now (maybe you edited in the post, or I'm just an idiot )

It was there from the initial post. (Not edited too!) =P No worries!