empirical data in true testing scenario with parser. http://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/t...ata-and-parser

TLDR
Warrior does more in the long run
Paladin can do more in the first rotation or 2

The outliers are minimal and the results are fairly accurate.

you are correct on the result not sure on the calculations because you are still missing a lot of things in the calculations you posted and I am going to stop messing with this and go back to playing the game.