Over-healing should not generate extra threat

[Dale]

If this happened healer would by far be the easiest class to play... Spamming heals requires absolutely no skill. No thank you, learn to play your class correctly, managing your threat is a huge part of being a healer. Also, your time could be better spent than standing there shooting off unnecessary heals, like maybe doing some damage? If you're unable to handle threat gen as a WHM, then maybe you should try SCH instead. (Or you know, don't be a healer if you can't handle it.)

Writing irritating posts that have no relation to anything I have said is waste of time too. But you still do it.

When did I ever say I shoot off unnecessary heals? When did I ever say I don't do any damage? You should spend your time reading posts before you respond to them with condescending trash like this. And at least do someone the courtesy of playing with them before you mock the way they play. I think people are entitled at least that common decency. Because believe it or not, reading my opinion that over-healing should not create extra threat doesn't make you an expert about me.

[Psychosamm]

Writing irritating posts that have no relation to anything I have said is waste of time too. But you still do it.

When did I ever say I shoot off unnecessary heals? When did I ever say I don't do any damage? You should spend your time reading posts before you respond to them with condescending trash like this. And at least do someone the courtesy of playing with them before you mock the way they play. I think people are entitled at least that common decency. Because believe it or not, reading my opinion that over-healing should not create extra threat doesn't make you an expert about me.

The only possible reason i could see someone complaining that over healing generates threat is because they themselves are having issues with threat gen. Just because you haven't yet learn how to manage your threat properly doesn't mean it should be removed from the game.
Plus it only makes sense that over healing creates threat. If you're attacking a pack of mobs, and one is doing a bunch of damage to you, you would want to kill it first, however if another mob is healing the shit out of it you're gonna think "Screw this i need to kill this healer mob first." It's the same principle. If the mobs aren't even seeing the tank take much damage because of over healing, they should want to kill the shit out of you. Period. Having your idea implemented would only make this game unnecessarily easier than it already is.